Assessment of the residual life of turbine runners with operational defectiveness

The residual life of the runners of hydraulic turbines in the presence of operational defects is estimated. The main problems of the operation of hydraulic turbines associated with technological defects and exhaustion of the standard resource are described. The main requirements for initial data to be used in estimation of the residual resource and the requirements for predicting the residual resource of runners based on the results of surveys and analysis of their technical condition are specified. We have classified and briefly described the applied approaches and techniques used in estimation of the residual resource. The main damaging factors affecting the residual life of the runners are revealed: deformation aging of the metal, cavitation, corrosion and fatigue damage to the elements of runners. The most characteristic defects are divided into three groups: zones of cavitation erosion; corrosion-fatigue cracks; and weld defects. Particular attention is paid to corrosion-fatigue cracks identified using flaw detection. The mechanism of crack formation and the most probable location of the cracks in the runner are shown. Statistical data on the number of cracks at the onset of the runner operation and at the time of shutdown maintenance are presented. The main statistical parameters of the sample and the parameters of crack size distributions including the distribution law are determined. The distribution law is exponential for the crack length parameter; whereas for the crack opening width it is log-normal. The revealed multidirectional cracks are located at the surface, subsurface or inner layer of the metal. They arise from operational defects (ulcers, craters, undercuts or delamination) and grow during operation of the turbine units. We also present the design schemes of elements with cracks used for quantification of resources according to the criteria of fracture mechanics. The results of calculations for static and dynamic crack resistance are presented as the dependence of stress intensity factors on the crack size. The levels of the total accumulated damage to the runners, the values of the residual life at the stage of crack nucleation and development were determined for 11 hydraulic units in the «start-stop» and «working» cycles. The main conclusion is that the total operating time of the hydraulic turbine runners significantly exceeds the standard operating life, while the residual resource is insufficient for a further period of long-term operation.

1. Makhutov N. A. Topical security issues of critical and strategic facilities / Zavod. Lab. Diagn. Mater. 2018. Vol. 84. N 1 – 1. P. 5 – 9 [in Russian]. DOI: 10.26896/1028-6861-2018-84-1-1-05-09

2. Georgievskaya E. V. The resource of hydraulic turbines is a guarantee of reliability and safety of HPP operation. Analytical review of literature. LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing, 2018. — 164 p. [in Russian].

3. Matvienko Yu. G., Reznikov D. O., Kuzmin D. A., Potapov V. V. Assessment of the probability of the fatigue fracture of structural components subjected to deterministic and stochastic loading taking into account the scatter in the initial crack size / Zavod. Lab. Diagn. Mater. 2021. Vol. 87. N 10. P. 44 – 53 [in Russian]. DOI: 10.26896/1028-6861-2021-87-10-44-53

4. Makhutov N. A., Gadenin M. M., Cherniavsky O. F., Cherniavsky A. O. Mechanical properties of materials in calculations of low cycle deformation of structures / Zavod. Lab. Diagn. Mater. 2022. Vol. 88. N 6. P. 52 – 59 [in Russian]. DOI: 10.26896/1028-6861-2022-88-6-52-59

5. Aniskovich E. V., Moskvichev V. V., Chernyaev A. P. Analysis of the results of diagnosing the impellers of hydraulic turbines of the Krasnoyarsk HPP during long-term operation / Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2019. N 10. P. 19 – 27 [in Russian].

6. Aniskovich E. V., Moskvichev V. V., Makhutov N. A., et al. Evaluation of residual stresses in the blades of the impellers of hydraulic units / Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2018. N 11. P. 178 – 184 [in Russian].

7. Destruction of the hydraulic unit N 2 of the Sayano-Shushenskaya hydroelectric power station: causes and lessons: a collection of materials. In 3 volumes. — Moscow: Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2013. Vol. 1. — 480 p.; V. 2. — 496 p.; V. 3. — 408 p. [in Russian]

8. Petreni Yu. K., Sudakov A. V. Strength and resource of power equipment / Proceedings of NPO CKTI. Issue 291. — St. Petersburg: NPO TsKTI, 2002. — 306 p. [in Russian]

9. Mikhailov V. E., Khomenok L. A., Sudakov A. V., Obukhov S. G. On the issue of complex diagnostics and examination of the state of equipment of TPPs and HPPs / Nadezhn. Bezopasn. Énerget. 2010. N 2. P. 9 – 14 [in Russian].

10. Smelkov L. L., Gavrilov S. N., Levina S. M., et al. Assessment of the residual life and the probability of failure-free operation of the hydraulic unit N 1 of the Irkutsk HPP / Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2009. N 9. P. 21 – 26 [in Russian].

11. Rzhanitsyn A. R. Theory of calculation of building structures for reliability. — Moscow: Stroyizdat, 1978. — 239 p. [in Russian].

12. Lepikhin A. M., Makhutov N. A., Moskvichev V. V., Chernyaev A. P. Probabilistic risk analysis of the designs of technical systems. — Novosibirsk: Nauka, 2003. — 174 p. [in Russian].

13. RF Pat. RU 2 721 514 C1, MPK G 05 B 23/00. Method for assessing the residual life of the impeller of a hydraulic turbine under design operating conditions / Georgievskaya E. V., Georgievsky N. V.; applicant and patent holder Georgievskaya E. V. — N 2019111714; appl. 17.04.2019; publ. 19.05.2020.

14. Kovchik S. E., Morozov E. M. Fracture mechanics and strength of materials: Reference book. In 4 vols. / Vol. 3. Characteristics of short-term crack resistance of materials and methods for their determination / V. V Panasyuk, Ed. — Kyiv: Naukova Dumka, 1988. — 434 p. [in Russian]

15. Romaniv O. N., Yarema S. Ya., Nikiforchin G. N. Fracture mechanics and strength of materials: Reference book. In 4 vols. / Vol. 4. Fatigue and cyclic crack resistance of structural materials / V. V. Panasyuk, Ed. — Kyiv: Naukova. Dumka, 1990. — 679 p. [in Russian]

16. Moskvichev V. V., Makhutov N. A., Shokin Yu. I., Lepikhin A. M. Applied problems of structural strength and fracture mechanics of technical systems. — Novosibirsk: Nauka, 2021. — 796 p. [in Russian]

17. Matvienko Yu. G. Models and Criteria of Fracture Mechanics. — Moscow: Fizmatlit, 2006. — 328 p. [in Russian]

18. Anderson T. L. Fracture Mechanics: Fundamentals and Applications. — Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1991. — 793 p.

19. Egusquiza E., Valero C., Xingxing H., Jou E., Guardo A., Rodriguez C. Failure investigation of a large pump-turbine runner / Engineering Failure Analysis. 2012. Vol. 23. P. 27 – 34.

20. Sivkov V. G. Problems of cracking in the blades of impellers of hydraulic units of the Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP / Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2003. N 11. P. 51 – 52 [in Russian].

21. Gabaidulin D. Yu., Grechneva M. V. Possibilities of restoring hydroturbine blades damaged by cavitation / Vestn. IrGTU. 2012. N 12. P. 40 – 43 [in Russian].

22. Murakami Yu. Handbook of stress intensity factors: In 2 vols. Vol. 2. — Moscow: Mir, 1990. — 1016 p. [Russian translation].

23. Lukinskiy V. S., Kotikov U. G., Zaicev E. I. Durability of vehicle chassis parts. — L.: Mashinostroenie, 1984. — 231 p. [in Russian].

24. Ivanchenko I. P., Prokopenko A. N. Analysis operational materials about educational cracks on radial axial water turbine blades of the Krasnoyarsk hydropower station / Gidrotekhn. Stroit. 2019. N 10. P. 6 – 18 [in Russian].